转写文本
Although I have to say, I certainly appreciate everyone's optimism and enthusiasm.
This is a real problem to solve, and a problem that is openly up for debate.
So I gravitate towards the challenging questions.
I think we have some interesting topics today.
So with that, soyer, if you don't mind, I'd love to have you kind of moderate and lead
here.
Yeah, sure.
So we're going to, it's possible far as odd in my join later and not sure TBD on that,
so no guarantees.
But it's just going to be the four of us up on stage for now.
And what we're going to do is I think, Ben, maybe first we'll start with sort of your
breakdown of what your idea is for transforming the cyber truck line, bringing it in-house
into up.
And then after that, we'll go through sort of the top five most upvoted questions that
the community had.
And then we'll sort of go through those one by one, we'll each give our thoughts on that.
And then I think after that we'll bring up maybe some of the audience members to give
their thoughts and opinions on some of the questions and whatnot.
Ben, maybe you just want to just give a quick overview on upplan your plan to sort of
take in the cyber truck line to up and build the cyber SUV.
Absolutely.
So firstly, I'm a cyber truck driver.
That's my daily.
And I've been through the highs and lows of the ownership experience with the cyber truck.
And by frankly, the only lows have been external events.
It has never been anything experientially.
The truck is the best vehicle I've ever driven.
And one of the interesting things about the cyber truck is that almost anyone you talk
to who's driven it tends to agree that it's the best vehicle at any price.
It doesn't matter.
It's a better driving experience.
And for that matter, transportation experience on FSD than anything, half million dollar
cars, whatever it might be, the cyber truck can do things that nothing else can't.
And so I feel like that's an amazing experience that people are still just starting to learn.
And it's challenging that it's so early in the product's evolution where I think it's
a highly understood platform.
And for those who know it, including its creators, especially, you know, this wouldn't
exist without the risk taking and general just all around engineering wizardry of Elon
and his team.
And, you know, Elon has said it's the best Tesla product ever made.
Granted that was at a prior moment in time.
But I would argue that it's still the best all around transportation experience Tesla
has.
Now, the cyber cab should probably make more money for Tesla.
Optimists will be the best product of all time for Tesla.
Those are my views.
But the cyber truck is immensely capable at what it does.
And so the viewpoint that I have is that we've not really yet seen the potential of the
cyber truck line.
And what I mean by line, and this is where the conversation tends to diverge a bit, is
I think the real value of the line is not one vehicle.
It's multiple.
And I think that the a theoretical free row SUV manufactured with a high percentage of
the same part content would by almost any measure outperform cyber trucks sales data.
And that has been somewhat subjective.
So a lot of what I've been trying to do over the past week or so is just to have conversations
and surface information.
At the end of the day, I have no power to make a decision on behalf of Tesla in order
to any of us.
And quite frankly, that's the way it should be.
Elon should run the company because he's the one who gave it life.
And he has better visibility on the facts than any of us do.
So the best hope that we have of trying to create the best outcome possible is to surface
all the facts and then leave it out there for Elon and his team to make a decision whenever
that day comes.
And if the decision is to stick with the plan that this line should be thrown in the scrap
we all need to accept that because at least from my side, I'm Ryder, Dye Tesla.
I've been a shareholder since 2012.
I bet my career, my company on it in 2013.
And it's been a very unlikely bet, but it's a bet on leadership.
Any company, if it's VC funded or whoever it is, it doesn't matter which embedding is leadership.
And Elon's leadership is unmatched and unarrivaled.
So it would be foolish to present the facts and a few things that this is a bad idea to
go against that.
Ultimately, my only goal is to get the information out there and to provide an option.
And quite frankly, I think this is an option that didn't exist before we presented it.
So that's the hope is to present at least a new option.
And we can dive into what that option entails, but no option is useful if it doesn't address
the core challenges.
And in piecing together what we can from Elon's decision to cancel the Cybertruck line,
which again, to me doesn't mean canceling Cybertruck, it means canceling Cybert SUV, it means
canceling potential cargo vehicles, it means the truck as well, it means anything that could
be made on that line that's designed for fully autonomous vehicles ever existing.
And by the way, as far as I think any public information is aware, it's the only line
that is really suited for off-road, which means everything from personal mobility on dirt
roads to potentially the moon and Mars and other things that could have SpaceX applications.
This line is uniquely suited for steering wheel lists, pedal lists, fully autonomous vehicles,
and the Cybert cab inherits the Cybert name because it shares some of the same attributes.
By almost any measure, the line that is proposed to being thrown away is closer to
Cybert cab into autonomy than the lines that are being promoted up right now, which is Model
Y. And this is not a knock on Model Y, I think it's a great product, but this is literally
the most high-tech line and vehicle Tesla has and the world has.
And so the premise of taking that and declaring it worthless and throwing it away to me feels
like there should be a lot of thought around that.
Not scrutiny, I don't use the word scrutiny, I use the word thought because we have to
solve for the problems.
And the problems, as Elon has described, are fair and clear, which is brain drain.
He wants everyone fully focused on presumably optimists, but especially Cybert cab at Tesla
and I'm sure data and chips and all the things that are adding real value to Tesla long-term,
and anyone who's working on anything that's not that presumably slows that down in some
form or fashion.
Then you have temporary constraints, battery cells, we can talk about that a bit.
And you have space constraints of where the line is located, relative to Cybert cab.
These are all real things, these are all things that come up.
And so any solution to them would, in theory, have to solve that or else we're always
wasting our time.
And so that kind of set the stage for me kind of grappling with this and trying to present
something that at least has a chance of checking all the boxes.
Now it's not easy.
And certainly, a lot of naysayers can bring challenges to the table and many have.
And that's good.
Because ultimately, if we can't address those challenges, head on and solve them, then
we have no business even talking about it.
So here we are.
I tried to go trial by fire as an approach and do everything in public and let everyone
find any vector of attack they can because I want to surface those challenges.
And an open conversation is really, I think all we can do for anyone interested in potentially
seeing a future where this line can be used to output vehicles.
And that output could be 100% Robotaxi network.
What I'm saying does not require it to be even sold a consumer.
I personally would want it to be sold a consumer, but there's many permutations of what
you can do with this line.
You could make only cargo and only SUV for only Robotaxi if you wanted from the same line
with relatively little lift.
You could have some combination of cars that have steering wheels and cars that don't.
You could have some mix of vehicles that are on the Robotaxi network and then ones that
are sold individuals.
You could have fractional ownership, something in between.
There's so many permutations, but when you throw away a line, you can throw away all of
that future with it.
So here we are.
That's the intro.
I guess the natural next question would be like, why would Tesla agree to this?
Like, what does Tesla get out of it?
We know the consumer angle.
Like, obviously they get the keep the vehicle alive.
They can keep purchasing stuff potentially.
But what does Tesla specifically get out of this?
Well, any deal that makes any sense for Tesla has to simultaneously give them more financial
upside than the alternative while being aligned with the mission of what the company stands
for, while not slowing down other activities that make them more money.
And what I've been trying to formulate, and it's effectively pieced together in the
proposal that I've put online, is something that aims to do all of that.
So first of all, it's extremely expensive to throw away a line that's already there.
The line doesn't pick up and walk itself out of the factory.
There's a lot of manpower and resource strain just to get rid of that line.
And so that's a sunk cost no matter what happens in this scenario.
But the question then becomes, is there a benefit of reoccurring revenue after that
line is theoretically discarded?
And so the proposal basically takes a number of things that, as a Tesla shareholder, I've
always wished what happened and puts them in defamation.
Number one, we've talked a lot, and I think every Tesla shareholder has talked a lot about
the premise of licensing FSD.
FSD, in autonomy, is Tesla's core technology for transportation.
There's yet to be a third party that's been able to license FSD.
And my personal belief is I think it's really hard to introduce FSD into a new vehicle
platform with a third party manufacturer that presumably takes a number of years.
Also, even more costly to Tesla, that presumably takes Tesla internal engineering and software
to integrate firmware into a third party product.
And right now, we array no Tesla's running as fast as they can at CyberCAD, an optimist.
So I suspect we're not seeing FSD third party licensing because it's damn hard to do.
This is a unique case where there is no engineering because it already exists.
FSD on the cyber truck's already there.
And continuation of that means effectively incremental free revenue for Tesla for every
additional vehicle sold.
And the essence of the proposal is that Tesla would make some percentage to be determined
of robot taxi revenue for any vehicle put on the robot taxi network.
FSD licensing for any FSD income that comes in plus a licensing fee for every vehicle
that's sold.
And then up and down the supply chain, there's opportunity for Tesla to make money and save
money.
For example, the cyber truck, you know, there's whatever number, 100 plus thousand on the
road.
I think Ben's coming down.
You could not view guys too.
Now we can hear him.
Cool, we can hear him.
Okay, it's just me then.
Sorry, sorry.
It's so, you know, I think by anyone's standard, Tesla is going to keep making products for
the cyber truck to support vehicles that need service down the road.
Tesla has actually done a remarkable job of providing service support over the year,
firmware updates to all of their legacy vehicles.
And so if Tesla has to manage third party supply chain for every component on the vehicle's
bomb and make all the components, then they can house continually and to stock them in
theory, everything they make is easier to source and cheaper per unit just to manage
their own service needs for the existing cyber trucks by having a continuation.
And so it's somewhat of a long-winded answer.
But effectively what I'm saying is that it's incremental value through multiple revenue
streams on every new vehicle produced.
Plus there's cost savings for what they have to do anyways to maintain the existing
line by having a partner that basically shares in that supply chain continuation.
And more simply said, if it doesn't make the money, they shouldn't do it.
So are there, do we lose you?
No, sorry, I was grabbing something.
Okay, so yeah, I mean, I love the cyber truck obviously.
It's a great, it drives great to features in it are awesome.
It can drive itself.
I think unfortunately, it's just the cost for Tesla was just too high and the product
just didn't quite resonate with as many people I think as it needed to.
I think if it were me though, I still would have attempted to sell the cyber SUV for a
while and just to see what the man was like for that.
Because I think that vehicle wouldn't have, you know, wouldn't have been a triangle first
of all.
And I think just people in general just prefer it prefer an SUV, even though the number
one selling car in America is a truck.
The truck is huge.
I think most people don't need the bed, but an SUV version I think would serve most
people's needs and I think could have been Tesla's like true big three row SUV.
I think the model YL is great, but it's not really competing with the likes of like,
let's say an escalator, you know, Chevy Suburban in terms of size.
I think people still want that big ass American SUV in the Tesla's lineup.
And it is interesting.
Last night Elon saying to Andrew Ross Orkin during an interview, he's like, the model YL is
our best selling car now, which is kind of surprising considering it's a higher selling
price.
If I had to, what if guess I would have thought the model Y premium all wheel drive this
order wheel based version, which is interesting.
A couple of quick thoughts on that, by the way.
Number one, I think that the cyber truck at a low enough price point is the volume mover.
And we never really, I think fully saw that realized that the current price point and
the historical price point, that market has always been family SUVs.
And so the question of where the volume is, I think, relates to where the pricing is.
If the cyber truck were sub 50,000, they could print those all day long presumably.
But at 80 plus, the SUV is always where the market is.
But I think, both of these might be barking up the wrong tree because the counter argument
is, and I'm not saying this is the case, but you have to also kind of play what if the
goal isn't to sell vehicles or what if the goal isn't to sell a high percentage of
vehicles.
And I kind of lean towards that the best outcome is one where you have modularity on the
same product line.
I think the best outcome is really a mix of vehicles that are on the